Ideas, originality, and copyright. Coldplay accused of infringement again.

One of these days we’ll learn what the KLF long ago tried to teach us about pop music: “Every Number One song ever written is only made up from bits from other songs. There is no lost chord. No changes untried. No extra notes to the scale or hidden beats to the bar. There is no point in searching for originality.”

Let’s get a basic point straight: copyright does not protect an idea. As the U.S. Copyright Office puts it: “Copyright does not protect facts, ideas, systems, or methods of operation, although it may protect the way these things are expressed. See Circular 1, Copyright Basics, section ‘What Works Are Protected.’”

So it may be true, as Consequence of Sound reports, that “just days after settling with Joe Satriani over plagiarism allegations, [Coldplay] is now being accused of copyright violations by UK musician Andy J. Gallagher for borrowing from Gallagher’s “Something Else” video with their video for ‘Strawberry Swing.’” But being accused of copyright violations and having those accusations deemed worthy of anything other than contempt are two entirely different things. As the Guardian explains, “there’s no doubt that [Gallagher's] and Coldplay’s music videos offer ‘an awful lot of similarities’. Or rather, one big similarity: they both show people interacting with animated chalk-boards.” And it may even be true that, as Gallagher complains, it seems “less than fair that [Coldplay's] video will win numerous awards and receive industry praise when [Gallagher's] director Owen Trevor had the idea the year before.”

But the answer is: so what? You cannot copyright the idea of a video involving people interacting with animated chalk-boards. As the producers of Coldplay’s video point out (pdf), the idea was hardly original with Gallagher. Nor do they claim originality; rather, they claim to have worked hard at making the Coldplay video:

We’re aware of those videos, and I don’t wish to denigrate them, but we thought there was more mileage in the technique than they had explored. We never claim to be original, just rigorous. So we wrote a story we thought would be entertaining and went about making it. It was a lot of hard work.

The specific video they produced may be original, but it hardly precludes anyone else from making videos involving people interacting with animated chalk boards.