Street Smarts, Book Smarts, and Making them Work Together

Scott Berkun compares “book smarts” to “street smarts” and concludes: “street smarts kicks book smarts ass.”

I agree, though, as does Berkun, in saying so I do not intend to demean the importance of book smarts. Street smarts, as Berkun explains, is the knowledge born of experience:

To be street smart means you have situational awareness. You can assess the environment you are in, who is in it, and what the available angles are. Being on the street, or in the trenches, or whatever low to the ground metaphor you prefer, requires you learn to trust your own judgment about people and what matters. This skill, regardless of where you develop it, is of great value everywhere in life regardless of how far from the streets you are.

Most important perhaps, being street smart comes from experience.

To me the most compelling part of Berkun’s post is his insistence that to be street smart is to rely on your own judgment, not the answers someone else has set out for you and you’ve found:

The prime distinction between street smarts and book smarts is who is at the center of the knowledge. On the street, it’s you. In a book it’s you trying to absorb someone else’s take on the world, and however amazing the writer is, you are at best one degree removed from the actual experience. Street smarts means you’ve put yourself at risk and survived. Or thrived. Or have scars. You’ve been tested and have a bank of courage to depend on when you are tested again.

I would only add that making your own judgment the center of book learning will make the book learning itself more effective. And you don’t need the experience of decades to do so. If you read to find answers without evaluating, trying out, and considering alternative to those answers, the answers are just so many abstract symbols that are virtually impossible to translate into future action. But if you do bring your own judgment and imagination to reading, you can make your street smarts improve your book smarts, and those improved book smarts will in turn improve your street smarts.