Make your point and move on; Fairey lied, but AP won’t establish he always does.

As I’ve said over and over again, lying messes you up. It robs you of credibility, a problem which inevitably is going to infect the decision maker’s view of the merits of your case. But when facing a liar, you can get carried away by his lies and take your eye off your own case. AP seems prone to this danger in its case against Shepard Fairey. Having established Fairey lied about knowing which photo he used in creating the Obama Hope poster, AP is now contending that Fairey lied when he claimed in January 2009 that he didn’t recall which photo he used.

I’m not sure why AP is pushing this point. First of all, it does not bear on the question of fair use at the heart of the case. Second, they’ve just been successful in establishing Fairey’s a liar. What more do they want? It will be far, far more difficult — and, as far as I can imagine, impossible — to establish that in January Fairey didn’t remember which photo he used (rather than incorrectly claiming later, after he’d reviewed his materials in connection with the preparation of the poster, which precise photo he’d used). And it’s not as if AP doesn’t have its own problems with credibility that it should make every effort to avoid.

And, again, as I wrote previously over at Remix America: Fairey and AP’s counter-accusations of illegitimate conduct are interesting but really irrelevant to the question of fair use in connection with the Obama Hope poster. So is the possibility that Garcia is lying about being angry at Fairey when Garcia first realized that the source of the poster was his photo. Of course, Garcia’s failure to realize this fact until he was told, even though he was very familiar with the poster, may be relevant — if the photographer didn’t realize the source was his photo, isn’t that some evidence the poster so thoroughly transformed the photo it stands on its own as a creative work?

But, more to the point of this post: if Garcia didn’t realize in January the photo was the source of the poster, isn’t it credible that Fairey didn’t either? AP gained ground this week in outing a lie; now it may be trying to go to that tactic too often.