J.D. Salinger may be a phony.

Don’t forget you read it here first: J.D. Salinger’s effort to stop the publication of a sequel to Catcher in the Rye on the grounds it infringes his copyright in the original novel is no sure thing either way. On the one hand, Holden Caulfield is very much his creation, and it seems the market Salinger has created by means of that creation might be considered his exclusive domain under copyright. But, then again, as copyright lawyer Marc Reiner said , the sequel “may qualify as a parody in the court’s eyes, as the ‘sequel’ puts the main character as an old man and may show a ‘transformative’ quality to the original-to what extent the book in question transforms the original work can affect whether it is seen as infringement.”

As I explained, this argument is founded principally upon the case in which the copyright owners of Gone with the Wind sued the writer of The Wind Done Gone. The court determined that The Wind Done Gone made fair use of the copyrighted characters and stories Gone with the Wind because “TWDG is more than an abstract, pure f ictional work. It is principally and purposefully a critical statement that seeks to rebut and destroy the perspective, judgments, and mythology of GWTW. Randall’s literary goal is to explode the romantic, idealized portrait of the antebellum South during and after the Civil War.”

Now I don’t think you have to rebut, destroy, and explode the original to constitute commentary constituting fair use upon the original. Nor is it easy for me to imagine a sequel that does not comment upon the original. And isn’t Holden Caulfield now such a cultural icon that he belongs to all of us, not just to J.D. Salinger?

But that’s going too far. I don’t think I could produce “Holden Caulfield” playing cards or action figures without J.D. Salinger’s consent. But if you can use Scarlett O’Hara in a sequel to Gone with the Wind that uses Gone with the Wind to make its own points, why can’t you use a Holden Caulfield nearing 80 to comment on Catcher in the Rye?