Compliments are worthless, and losing is winning: lawyering in a nutshell

From The Namby Pamby, Attorney at Law, comes this story, which sums up concisely both what so much of legal practice is about and why it is so often difficult for students to grasp exactly what it is they’re supposed to be doing:

Eight months, untold amounts of hours, it all came to this

For the second time in the last month, my brief writing was complimented by a judge:

“Counsel, this was excellently briefed, well done…I’m going to deny your motion.”
Thanks.

The lesson here is to beware the judicial compliment.

The reality is that even though we lost our motion, we did serious (perhaps fatal) damage to the opposing side. My boss was happy. Ergo, despite my failure at a judicial declaration of winning, we still won.