How creative does a work need to be to win the Brit Insurance Design Award?

The British Design Museum gave its Brit Insurance Design Award 2009 to Shepard Fairey for his Obama Hope poster. Nominations for the award were made by “a group of internationally respected design experts, curators, critics, practitioners, enthusiasts.”

Do you think the Design Museum considered Fairey’s poster a sufficiently creative transformation of the photograph from which it was derived to be a non-infringing fair use of the photograph? Do you think AP is spending its money wisely in challenging Fairey’s right to use the photograph?

Edward Morris: “Fairey is not plagarizing or stealing! Get with the program on appropriation art, ok!”